All kids count -- and should be counted!

Coalition for Transparency in Public Education

reading in braille

We need to know what's happening to our kids

Discrimination on the basis of minority status or disability status is still a problem in NYS

Background on "Aversives" Regulations

 

At their June 2006 meeting, the NYS Board of Regents approved "emergency" regulations that while appearing to prohibit the use of "aversive behavioral interventions" -- such as electric skin shock, ammonia sprays, hot pepper sauce on disabled student's tongues -- actually legitimized the use of such techniques for every public school, preschool, state-approved private school, and BOCES facility . A copy of the regulations were posted on NYSED's site. You can also download a copy from this site in pdf format.

 

NYSED has also uploaded its procedures by which CSEs essentially decide to grant themselves child-specific waivers -- even if the Commissioner's Expert Panel strongly cautions against it:

 

By presenting the regulations as "emergency" regulations, the NYS Education Department did not have to have a period for public input and commentary. The regulations went into effect on June 23, and then there was a period of public feedback that concluded in August. At their September meeting, the Board of Regents approved an emergency extension of the emergency amendments.

 

Following review of all the public input, the Regents were provided with revised amendments at their October meeting. The Board of Regents will be voting at their January 2007 meeting as to whether to approved the revised amendments.   There was a one-month period for the public to provide written feedback on the revised amendments; no public hearings were scheduled, and written feedback was due by Dec. 15, 2006.

 

Documents

 

The Coalition's written testimony sent to VESID and the Regents following the June amendments is available here. The Coalition's written testimony sent to VESID and the Regents following the revised emergency amendments issued in November is available here.

 

The New York State Psychological Association's Task Force on the Use of Aversive Controls with Children also provided written feedback to the proposed amendments in August. You can read their report here; the Executive Summary is also available here. The Task Force also responded to the revised proposed amendments in December 2006; that report is available here.

 

The NYCLU issued a press release and provided written feedback in August. They also provided written feedback to the revised proposed amendments in December 2006.

 

The following are some other responses to the regulations. The individuals mentioned below are not all Coalition members, but we want you to know what others are saying, as well.

  • Coalition co-founder Dee Alpert attended the public hearing in Albany and provided oral testimony. You can read her individual written testimony.
  • Coalition co-founder Jo Anne Simon attended the public hearing in NYC and provided oral testimony on behalf of the Coalition.
  • Jaclyn Okin Barney of the NYLPI also testifed at the NYC hearing. You can read NYLPI's testimony.
  • Coalition co-founder Leslie Packer attended the public hearing in NYC, and presented oral testimony on behalf of the NYS Psychological Association Task Force on the Use of Aversive Controls with Children.
  • Victor Clark, father of a child with Down Syndrome and autism, made a moving statement to prohibit aversives.
  • Assemblyman Richard N. Gottfried's letter to the NYS Board of Regents.

 

If your organization has issued a statement on these regulations, please send us a copy by email to info@transparencyinpubliceducation.org  

 

 

Update

 

NBC News Channel 4 did a piece on the aversives regulations and the controversy on Thursday, Dec. 14th. The video is currently available on their web site. Just click on the link to the video that says "Torture or Discipline?"

 

Coalition co-founder Dee Alpert has sent a statement to the Regents that puts them on formal notice that NYSED is misrepresenting the situation with respect to the federal law and with respect to the issue of the sexual molestation of seriously disabled students (discussed on another section of this web site). You can read Dee's powerful statement to the Regents here.

 

Jan. 7, 2007: Maia Szalavitz has an op-ed in the NY Times, "Shocks to the System." (free reg. may be required for NYT)

 

Jan. 8, 2007: The NYCLU has issued another press release urging the Regents to ban aversives. The release also contains a link to the NYCLU's written response to revised proposed amendments (pdf).

 

 

This page last updated January 8, 2007

 

 

Text Links to Site Sections

 

Alerts
News
About
Reports
Media
Home

 

Lawsuit

 

Judge Rotenberg Center and Families Sue NYSED

In August, some of the families of students at JRC filed suit in U.S. District Court, essentially asking the court to enjoin NYSED from enforcing a ban on the use of electric skin shock for their children. Media coverage of the suit can be found here.

 

A limited temporary restraining order has been issued (see below), and the matter is scheduled for pre-trial conference on October 19th.

 

Court-Related Documents: